It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas – baking! We’re here to help your pre-holiday planning by providing a handy list of Christmas cookie icing options. A common Christmas cookie question (besides “Are they done yet?”) is “What kind of icing should I use?” The answer is  largely dependent on the kind of cookie, whether you expect that cookie to travel and where you fall on the question: does Santa prefer decorated or undecorated cookies? Very serious stuff. Let’s dive in!

Homemade Royal Icing

Perhaps the most popular of the cookie icings, royal icing has many advantages: it’s easy to make, lactose-free, has endless decorating possibilities and it dries hard so that you can stack your cookies for transport. This recipe scores big with roll-out cookie lovers, since the sweetness of confectioners’ sugar balances nicely with a less-sweet cookie. It’s also the perfect icing for building and decorating gingerbread houses, a classic Christmas craft.

Wilton Cookie Icing

Our ready-to-use option scores big points with bakers on the go. It comes in a variety of colors, dries smoothly and comes in a squeezable, microwaveable bottle. Simply pipe the outline with icing straight from the bottle, then microwave to flood. Unlike royal icing, this icing doesn’t dry hard, so place them in a single layer on a plate or skip the extra cleanup by baking, decorating and serving them on our adorable Bake and Bring snowflake-print cookie sheets! Find our cookie icing here.

Homemade Buttercream Frosting

For dimensional decorations like wreaths and roses, or to give your cookies that cupcake mouthful-of-frosting appeal, buttercream is a versatile choice. Our vanilla recipe is a classic flavor that works wonderfully as a filling for sandwich cookies. Too vanilla? Get into the holiday spirit and experiment by using any of our many buttercream recipes to add flavor and bit of festive flair to your favorite cookie recipe.

At the end of the day, whether you want a shiny royal icing finish or a soft, boiled buttercream frosting filling, Christmas cookies are about baking the joy of the season into a yummy little package that delivers smiles to all who eat it. After all, smiling is our favorite.

Share your smile-worthy Christmas cookies with us by commenting below or sharing your photos on Instagram and tagging @WiltonCakes.

Share Your Treats!

Be sure to tag your photo